Showing posts with label Yankees. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Yankees. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 13, 2015

If I Were....


Most of my friends who are also parents lament in the fact that their children are growing up so fast. While I can somewhat empathize, one of the changes in their “likes” that I am completely on board with is the change in their musical tastes. The kiddie songs they enjoyed as toddlers were extremely grating to my audio senses. One that I remember distinctly was a song the boys sang in Sunday School that would get stuck in my head and drive me to the brink of insanity – “If I Were a Butterfly”. They would sing the song and then my wife would join in and then I would pull my hair out…. not literally.

But if I thought about it, the concept of the song isn’t a bad idea. Today I give to you my version of the song, slightly altered, called “If I Were MLB Commissioner” …

The first thing I would do as MLB Commissioner is to get that crazy aforementioned song out of my head, while priming myself for what is about to come by blasting David Bowie’s classic song, “Changes”.

Oh yeah, changes are a comin’!! Now before you start calling me an old fogey and a “purist” just know that some of the changes I would be proposing are forward-thinking. Stick with me!

First and foremost, the 2015 season brought about issues that need to be addressed, headlined by the finish in the NL Central. The top three teams in the division had the top three records in all of baseball. Yet, two of them only get one game to continue playing in the playoffs. Not only that, but the winner then plays the team with the best record in all of baseball! After the NLDS only ONE of the top 3 records in all of MLB will still be playing. That seems wrong altogether. However, division winners should still receive benefits. How we correct that? Realignment!!!

The first issue with creating equal opportunity in the playoffs is evening the leagues. Yes, they currently have the same amount of teams. However, each league has 15 teams which is the unevenness that I speak of. Jeff Passan of Yahoo recently wrote about getting rid of divisions and leagues altogether. I’m not going to get that crazy, but changes need to be made. I believe the NHL has the best playoff system around and that is my model for the new playoff system. The concern is getting to an even number. Do I contract two teams to get to 28 or do I add two teams to get to 32? The numbers make ALL of the difference in this situation. And I like options. Here are the three models I was deciding between:
  1. Add two teams: Four 4-team divisions in each league. 18 games vs division, 9 each remaining team in the league
  2. Add two teams: Two 8-team divisions in each league. 18 games vs division, 4 games with four teams in other division, 5 games with other four teams in division
  3. Retract two teams: Two 7-team divisions. 19 games vs division, 6 games with teams in other division.
Take note – NO MORE INTERLEAGUE play. In my opinion, it takes away from the All-Star Game and the World Series. Therefore, it goes bye-bye.

I’m sure you’re wondering how the playoffs would work in each scenario. Well, I’m glad you asked. Here they are (with the corresponding number):
  1. Only the four division winners would make the playoffs. Seeded by record from best to worst. Division series and LCS would be seven games.
  2. NHL style playoff system. Top 3 teams in each division make the playoffs. Division winners get byes for first round. #2 seed in Division A plays #3 seed in Division B (reverse is true as well). These series are three games. Division winners have home field for Division Series (best of five). LCS is seven games.
  3. Two division winners and three Wild Card teams (next three best records). 2nd and 3rd Wild Card teams play 3 game series day after season ends (1/2 format with better record getting two home games). Winner gets to play division winner with best record. 1st Wild Card plays division winner with lesser wins. These series are five games. LCS is seven games.
My choice – 1. While I love the Wild Card and all the drama it brings, I believe a one game playoff in baseball just isn’t realistic. There are way too many variables coming in to play that can affect a one game playoff. MLB cares about ratings which is why they love the Wild Card, but I’ve always been a proponent of being rewarded for a job well done. And if you realign the divisions via the NFL then a four team division can have a clear winner. However, since there are only 30 teams two would need to be added in order to reach the requisite 32 teams for this particular alignment. There are four cities I have in mind that could possibly support a major league team are San Antonio, Las Vegas, Charlotte and Orlando. Depending on which teams are approved and such (all those details including the expansion draftvwould take up WAY too much of this column), here’s how I would realign the leagues and divisions if I were Commissioner:

Division Alignment:
American League
East – Yankees, Red Sox, Orioles and Blue Jays
South – Royals, Astros, Rangers and new San Antonio/Las Vegas team
North – White Sox, Twins, Tigers and Indians
West – Angels, Mariners, A’s and Rockies

National League
East – Mets, Nationals, Phillies and Pirates
South – Braves, Marlins, Rays and new Charlotte/Orlando team
North – Cubs, Cardinals, Brewers and Reds
West – Dodgers, Giants, Diamondbacks and Padres

There is some movement among leagues and teams, but the geographical aspect looms large in my mind. Cutting down on the travel would produce better baseball, in my opinion. Therefore, the shorter the distance between teams in a division, with all the games being played amongst them, would benefit the teams. The major change are the Rockies moving to the American League. First and foremost, having a DH in Colorado would produce more runs, which brings in viewers. Do I like the DH? No. I believe everyone that plays should have and use a glove. However, I also understand the power and complexity of the MLB Players Association and with all the changes coming, throwing out an olive branch would help. Another team moving would be the Rays moving to the NL South. Again, this change was predicated on a more regional look for the division and less grueling travel. Three Florida teams and an Atlanta team in the same division solves that issue.

So, how would that look? Here’s how this year’s records would fall into place with the new alignment (granted, I understand the records would be different because of the new schedule format, but throw me a bone…):

AL East
  1. Blue Jays                 93-69
  2. Yankees                   87-75
  3. Orioles                     81-81
  4. Red Sox                   78-84
AL South
  1. Royals                      95-67
  2. Rangers                    88-74
  3. Astros                       86-76
  4. San Antonio/Las Vegas
AL North
  1. Twins                        83-79
  2. Indians                      81-80
  3. White Sox                 76-86
  4. Tigers                        74-87
AL West
  1. Angels                      85-77
  2. Mariners                   76-86
  3. Athletics                   68-94
  4. Rockies                    68-94 
Already you can see that they playoffs change – Yankees, Astros, and Rangers don’t make the playoffs while the Twins do make the postseason. But again, you’ve got to give to get… Let’s look at the National League

NL East
  1. Pirates                      98-64
  2. Mets                         90-72
  3. Nationals                  83-79
  4. Phillies                     63-99

NL South
  1. Rays                         80-82
  2. Marlins                     71-91
  3. Braves                      67-95
  4. Orlando/Charlotte

NL North
  1. Cardinals                100-62
  2. Cubs                         97-65
  3. Brewers                    68-94
  4. Reds                         64-98
NL West
  1. Dodgers                   92-70
  2. Giants                      84-78
  3. D-Backs                  79-83
  4. Padres                     74-88 
The feel good story of the playoffs so far, and MY team, the Cubs would be out of the playoffs while a team under .500, the Rays would be included. I believe this would be different than the NFL (and an anomaly) because the Rays played against the AL East this year – and their record would be much different playing against the Braves, Marlins and an expansion team – so keep that in mind.

Playoffs would like like the following:
American League
Royals v Twins – Royals with home field advantage
Blue Jays v Angels – Blue Jays with home field advantage

National League
Cardinals v Rays – Cardinals with home field advantage
Pirates v Dodgers – Pirates with home field advantage

The home field advantage in the World Series would be determined by the best overall record between the two teams. Should there be a tie, the tiebreaker would best league record followed by best divisional record.

These changes would also filter down to the All-Star Game, which reverts back to being a true exhibition. While we’re at it – let’s carve up that weekend as well. I enjoy the Futures Game and it will stay. The HR Derby changes this year were fantastic and brought more drama and less downtime then years before, so I would keep it as well. One minor thought I would consider for the HR Derby…if fans like the long HR’s so much let the players use the old aluminum bats and let’s really see how far some of these mashers can drive a baseball.
I do like the thought of a skills competition though – events like fastest around the bases, throwing for accuracy from the outfield, fastest pitch, catchers accuracy to second base, etc… Finally, the game itself. I empathize with the fans who want to see a player from their team at the ASG. But IF this is a feature to keep for the fans, then we will expand the rosters so that more players can experience the weekend and get a change to play.

Well, there you have it. Just a FEW of the changes I would make if I were the Commissioner of Major League Baseball. Hopefully, your thoughts have been stirred (whether you agree or not) and with a bit of luck you don’t have an annoying song stuck in your head.


Monday, April 06, 2015

The Cardinals and Scottie Pippen

Since there is already trolling after ONE GAME, I felt the need to post this again. I'll be back later tonight with my weekend thoughts...

*******

I grew up in Central Illinois, just north of Peoria, in a little town called Chillicothe. It was a big baseball area and the fan lines were drawn between the Cubs and the Cardinals. It was almost as if the AL only existed to get beat in the All-Star Game and then play in the World Series. My family was a die-hard Cubs family. I liked to tell people, once I got to college and beyond, that where I grew up you rooted for the Cubs or the Cardinals and my Dad brought me up right. Yes, there as quite a bit of playful animosity between the two fan bases since they were rivals, but other than 1984 when the Cubs finally went to the playoffs after 39 years, the Cardinals ruled the rivalry. As I have grown older the “playful” part of the enmity has gone by the wayside. It’s nice to have a rival – I’m a huge Bears fan and we hate the Packers, but I respect loyal Packers fans – but there is an underlying issue that has been bothering me for a while…. and I think I might have stumbled across some reasons as to the purpose of this enmity.

Let me go back to my Little League days to help explain my theory. I LOVED Little League. After Valentine’s Day I would get the itch for practices and bug my Dad about signups. I lived for the summers when I could play all day and all weekend. My birthday was in the middle of August, which doesn’t seem like a big deal at first glance, but my parents started me in school early. I was always the youngest person in my class. As the related to Little League, I hardly even played with my classmates. Most of my teams consisted of guys who were a year behind me in school. I also had an older brother, two years my senior, who played as well. I always watched and studied my classmates and my older brothers teams and noticed a few interesting tidbits.

I can’t explain it, but there was always one guy who was far and away the best player. Usually, this was the guy who matured the fastest and therefore could throw faster and hit it further than the rest of the team. Two names stand out for me, Bill Akright and Dana Bannister. Both were absolute flamethrowers who scared the bejesus out of any little kid, like me, who had to face them. Now, I’m not tooting my own horn, but I was a pretty good ball player. Never the first pick, but I considered myself a dirtbag who would do anything to win. Consequently, there were times where I got called up to the leagues above me to substitute for missing players. A very cool reward…unless I ended up having to face Akright or Bannister – then it was just making sure I didn’t piss down my leg as I walked to the plate.

A little about me: yes, I was a scrappy ballplayer, but once boys got to the age where physical things started to happen, I stalled. To say I was a late bloomer is a gross understatement. Let me put it plainly for you – the day I graduated high school I was 5’3” tall….and I had grown about 3 inches the last nine weeks of my senior year. Make sense now? I digress. When I played Little League these giants throwing BB's at what seemed like 100 mph scared me to death. I didn’t back down but I was never hugely successful when I got called up. I liked playing with my own age group. Again, there was always the easy first pick for any coach putting together any of my teams. After that though, it got interesting. After the mega-starts were a lot of really good ballplayers. At the time, I liked to fancy myself as one, but who knows how they looked at me. These guys were so close in talent that the position they chose could make all the difference in the world in getting noticed. My brother is a great example of this – he was a catcher (I was too, but also played the other positions up the middle of the field in 2B and CF) so he set himself apart. Was he the mega-star? No. But he was a really good player who played a vital position. One thing that always bit my brother and me in the rear in Little League was that we didn’t play the political game. We didn’t toot our own horns and neither did our Dad. Our play would tell the story. I understand that choice.

So how does this all this relate to Cubs and Cardinals fans? Let’s connect the dots. There were three major types of players in Little League – the mega-stars, the really good players who had to be political to get ahead, and the little scrappy guys (like me) who just wanted to play all day long but would never carry a team. I think we can correlate each of these players with a team in MLB today – the mega-star would be the Yankees. 27 World Championships is all we need to day about that classification. The really good player would be the Cardinals – 11 World Championships, great history, but will never reach the Yankees level. Finally, the little scrappy kid – that’s the Cubs – think Squints from the movie “The Sandlot” or Tanner from “Bad News Bears”. He needs a LOT of help from better players to help them win. In my opinion, Cardinals fans HATE being the really good player who never seemingly gets his due. They want to be the alpha dog who can preen and pose while everyone ooh’s and ah’s at their greatness. That’s not going to happen – ever.

We can classify this as the Scottie Pippen complex, if I may. He is one of the 50 greatest NBA players of all time. But he will never be Mike. When Michael went to play baseball and Scottie was left to be “the man”, what happened? Nothing. Once Scottie left Chicago did he ever win anything? Nope.

For me, the classic example was Wilber Marshall. LOVED this guy when he was with the Bears; he was my second favorite player after Walter. He was a beast. But when he became a FA he bolted to be the man in Washington and…he was never the same. Yes, he won a ring there but he was never the main cog of the defense.

This is the problem with Cardinals fans. They want the adulation for being a Jordan when they are a Pippen. Let me clarify – there is absolutely nothing wrong with being a Pippen. But you can’t expect to be looked at as a Jordan when you aren’t Jordan. That’s the Yankees. So to make themselves feel better – they pick on the Penny Hardaway of the group, the Cubs. Yes, we’ve had a few great years but could never put it all together to win the title. The more Cardinals fans feel disrespected, the more Penny gets derided.

Yogi Berra had a famous line as he was talking to Bernie Williams during the 1999 ALCS. He said, “Relax. We've been playing these guys for 80 years. They're never gonna beat us." What a dig! There aren’t many things more derisive than indifference. The Yankees (until 2004) were indifferent towards the Red Sox because they knew they would always beat them. Why aren’t Cardinals fans like that towards Cubs fans? Can we help it that the media is fascinated with the “lovable loser” tag (I HATE that moniker)? That we have an historic ballpark with ambiance in a great neighborhood that sells out every game? It is not our fault, as Cubs fans, that the media has made the club and their fans darlings because of on the field failures; billy goats, called HR shots, Leon’s glove, Bartman….it’s all a fascinating story. But if I was a Cardinals fan (and I shudder at the thought) I would have indifference towards the Cubs until they actually won something.

Give it a try Cardinals fans, ignore us. Enjoy being Scottie Pippen. Maybe someday we will get a chance to be Luke Walton.